Ethical Considerations
An approach to symptom management to guide decision-making in the management of patients with life-threatening illness
Beneficence and Non-maleficence
Respect for autonomy (self-rule)
Introduction
We recognise that patients diagnosed with life-threatening or terminal illness are vulnerable in their emotional state and dependence on their health care professionals (& non-professionals) for compassionate empathetic care, sensitive sharing of information to promote participation in decision-making and effective symptom management. It is essential that HCPs caring for patients with life-threatening illness base their care on sound ethical principles & practice. The following is an outline of ethical principles as applicable to end-of-life care.
Beneficence and Non-maleficence
- Treatment can only be justified if there is benefit to the patient
- In clinical care, balance benefit of treatment vs risk of treatment
- If there is no longer any benefit to the patient withholding or withdrawing treatment is a sound medical decision which may be reached in discussion with patient, family and carers
- Try to ensure continuity of care and appropriate referral if you are no longer the treating clinician
- A principle of palliative care is non-abandonment, there is always an appropriate treatment plan
- Referral to hospice or palliative care service if symptom control is not achieved within time frame specified in individual care plan.
- Rigorous & effective professional education of HCPs to develop competence in palliative care will promote beneficence, as will effective medical & palliative care research
Respect for autonomy (self-rule)
- Promote patient understanding to be able to provide informed consent
- providing sufficient information to enable a person to participate fully in decision-making
- promotes confidentiality and privacy
- Respects a person's refusal of treatment following sharing of information with the person concerned
- Patient autonomy is based on good communication, and promoting of patient’s understanding
- Empowerment combines autonomy and beneficence
Justice
- Distributive justice
- distribution of scarce resources
- Rights based justice
- equal access to health care
- right to palliative care
- right to pain and symptom control
- right to competent, trained clinician
- Legal justice
- in accordance with the laws of the state