Treatment
These are the approved guidelines published by the South African Society of Psychiatrists to provide an overview on treatment and management of commonly diagnosed psychiatric illnesses. The guidelines include consensus recommendations, based on peer contribution and using the international evidence based guidelines that are suitable for the local South African health service.
Please note that parts of this guideline may be out of date, an update will be published as soon as it is available.
Managing partial and non responders
Treatment goals
The goal of treatment of GAD is reduction and ideally elimination of symptoms or worry and anxiety, and restoration of normal functioning.[10]
General aspects of treatment
The initial treatment of GAD can arguably be either medication or psychotherapy as both approaches are efficacious. Several factors may complicate GAD, thus impacting on decisions about the choice of pharmacotherapy and other interventions. The most important factors, along with their treatment implications, are listed below. In addition, prior response to treatment and patient preference are important considerations.
Geriatric patients
Research indicates that GAD in the elderly is not uncommon and is often accompanied by depression.[11] Given the possibility of accumulation of the drug and consequent adverse effects such as motor vehicle accidents, falls and fractures, benzodiazepines (particularly in high doses or those with long half-lives) should be prescribed only with great caution in this population. In addition, dosages of many other psychotropic medications require adjustment in the elderly.
Alcohol and/or substance use
When the diagnosis of GAD predates the onset of substance abuse, treatment may be initiated relatively soon after abstinence. However, when symptoms of anxiety have their onset during substance abuse or withdrawal, it is likely that a longer period of abstinence is indicated prior to re-evaluation of the need for treatment. In addition, given the risk of dependence, benzodiazepines should be used with caution in patients with a history of substance abuse.[12]
Other comorbid disorders
As noted earlier, there is a high rate of comorbidity among GAD, other anxiety disorders and mood disorders. GAD will often respond to the antidepressants that are used as first-line medication in these disorders, and these agents should therefore be considered initially. Similarly, in patients with chronic anxiety and comorbid personality disorder (e.g. borderline personality disorder), antidepressants may be a consideration.
Pregnancy, lactation, menopause
Pharmacotherapy should ideally be avoided during pregnancy and lactation. Nevertheless, where clinical considerations outweigh the risk of medication, such intervention should be considered after consultation with a specialist. In particular, there is a growing literature pointing toward relative safety of fluoxetine in pregnancy.[13] Certain benzodiazepines (e.g. chlordiazepoxide) may be safer, while others (e.g. alprazolam) should be avoided during pregnancy and lactation; the lowest effective dose should be prescribed for the shortest possible duration, and high peak concentrations should be avoided by dividing the daily dosage into two or three doses.[14] Anxiety symptoms may be exacerbated in susceptible patients during menopause, and hormone replacement therapy may be considered as an adjunct to standard pharmacotherapy.
Comorbid medical disorders and medications
Clinicians need to be aware of the multiple interactions between medications used in the treatment of GAD and the treatment of other disorders, as well as of the impact of the medication's adverse effects on medical disorders.
Pharmacological treatment
The first-line treatment of uncomplicated GAD is a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) or serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (SNRI) drug. Given the substantial comorbidity of GAD with depression and other disorders for which antidepressants are effective, expert consensus favours the use of one of these agents.[15,16] However, there is evidence for a range of other agents, including pregabalin, agomelatine, older antidepressants such as tricylics (TCAs), benzodiazepines, the azapirone buspirone, the antihistamine agent hydroxyzine, the first-generation antipsychotic trifluoperazine and the second-generation antipsychotic quetiapine.[2,17]
A recent meta-analysis and systematic review of the efficacy of nine drug treatments for GAD notes advantages and disadvantages of several of these agents.[18] For example, the TCAs (namely imipramine) have been shown effective in GAD in several controlled trials, but are currently considered a second-line option owing to their adverse event burden and toxicity in overdose.[19] Similarly, given concerns about their tolerability and side-effect profile, caution should be exercised in using atypical and typical antipsychotic medications as monotherapy in GAD.
The benzodiazepines are best reserved for short-term use (2 - 4 weeks) in the early phase of treatment of GAD with an SSRI or SNRI to provide some symptomatic relief until the antidepressant has begun to work, to treat insomnia if it is a predominant symptom, and to protect against occasional early worsening of anxiety seen with the initiation of therapy.[19] The high comorbidity of symptoms of depression in GAD, and the significant difficulties experienced by many patients during benzodiazepine withdrawal, constitute a strong argument against their long-term use. Benzodiazepines with longer half-lives or slow-release preparations may, however, be associated with fewer withdrawal problems.
Buspirone, a 5-HT1A agonist, takes 2 - 4 weeks or longer to begin working, and appears to be experienced as less helpful in patients recently treated with benzodiazepines.[20] Its advantage lies in its benign side-effect profile, the lack of dependence, and its proven efficacy in GAD. Disadvantages include a lack of efficacy against the depressive symptoms often found in GAD, and a lack of efficacy in some trials. Whereas some SSRIs have been shown useful in children and adolescents with GAD, a controlled study of buspirone in this population was negative.
Although beta-blockers (e.g. propranolol) are often prescribed by general practitioners for anxiety symptoms, they have unproven efficacy in GAD. Kava extract is a herbal that showed some promise for the treatment of anxiety,[21] but it has not been studied rigorously enough in GAD, and there are safety concerns, viz. hepatotoxicity.
Non-pharmacological treatment
Cognitive-behavioural treatment (CBT) has demonstrated efficacy in GAD, where the benefits are maintained at 6 months to 2 years of follow-up.[22] Treatment of GAD using CBT involves techniques of cognitive restructuring, worry exposure, and behaviour modification. There is currently little evidence that routinely initiating CBT together with medication improves outcome in GAD.
Acute treatment
The response time to a first-line SSRI (e.g. fluoxetine, citalopram, escitalopram, paroxetine, sertraline) or SNRI (e.g. venlafaxine, duloxetine) is usually between 4 and 12 weeks in GAD, although with adequate dosing a partial response may be evident by 4 - 6 weeks.[2,23]TCAs and benzodiazepines are also efficacious in the treatment of GAD, but are not considered first-line in view of their adverse event profile (see below). Buspirone is another option in the treatment of GAD (see below).
The first step after drug initiation is to determine response to the medication. This is achieved by careful evaluation of change in symptoms initially targeted for treatment. These are typically excessive worry, various somatic symptoms, and consequent functional impairment. Determining the side-effects of the medication is also important, as these may influence compliance. Patients who are intolerant of a particular medication can of course be switched to another agent or to another class of agents. For example, within the SSRIs, adverse effects may not be seen when an alternative SSRI is used.
When there is a poor response to medication, the first course of action is to optimise dose and duration of the treatment. For many of the antidepressants, there is a relationship between dose and response and also between dose and side-effects. Thus, optimal dosage is as close to maximum recommended doses that the patient can tolerate. Elderly patients generally require lower doses than younger adults. Particularly in the case of the TCAs, clinicians often prescribe suboptimal doses, rather than using doses of 150 mg or more of medications such as imipramine. Even in the case of the SSRIs, some patients may fail to respond to the standard initial starting dose, but do better at higher doses.
Furthermore, there is increasing awareness that some patients maybe rapid metabolisers of antidepressant medication and, therefore, require significantly higher doses than usual. When patients on TCAs have little response and few anticholinergic side-effects on average doses of medication (e.g. imipramine 150 mg), it may be useful to further increase dosage with electrocardiogram and perhaps drug level monitoring.
Although benzodiazepines are not recommended as first-line treatments, when used, they should be prescribed in an optimal fashion. In particular, it may be useful to replace short-acting agents with slow-release compounds or long-acting agents. All too frequently, patients on short-acting compounds have intermittent increases of anxiety before the next dose of medication is to be taken.
Buspirone treatment usually begins at 5 mg three times daily. This dose may be increased by 5 mg every 2 - 3 days. Therapeutic doses of buspirone range from 30 mg to 60 mg daily, typically given in divided doses. Buspirone has at least a 2 - 4 week time lag from initiation to clinical onset; optimum duration of a trial of treatment should thus be no less.
At the end of a clinical trial of optimal dose and duration, patients should be thoroughly reassessed. There is growing recognition of the importance of residual anxiety symptoms in causing disability and predicting relapse, and of the consequent necessity of aiming for remission of symptoms as the endpoint of treatment.[24]
Maintenance treatment
When the patient has a good response to medication, it is important to reinforce the necessity for continuing the medication at the therapeutic dose despite this improvement.[25] It is recommended that therapy be continued for at least 1 year where there is a good response, given that the disorder is chronic and randomised controlled trials have demonstrated relapse with shorter-term maintenance. It is also important to regularly monitor efficacy and tolerability during long-term treatment. Indeed, guidelines for maintenance therapy of GAD emphasise the safety of modern agents, the likelihood of additional episodes of illness in patients with repeated past episodes, and the theoretical possibility that appropriate treatment may prevent the onset of secondary disorders.[15] Such guidelines have become increasingly conservative, favouring longer courses of medication. When a decision is made to discontinue medication, a gradual taper is recommended (arguably with an even slower taper in the elderly and in medically ill patients).
Managing partial and non-responders
When GAD does not respond to a clinical trial of adequate dose and duration, it may be useful to reassess a number of important factors that may influence choice of further interventions.
Comorbidity
It is important to establish whether comorbid mood or other anxiety disorders are present. For example, comorbid dysthymia may not respond to buspirone alone, comorbid social anxiety disorder is unlikely to respond to a TCA (other than clomipramine), and comorbid hypochondriasis may require high doses of SSRIs. Excluding important comorbid psychiatric disorders is perhaps the most important step in the evaluation and management of refractory GAD.
Compliance
Many patients with GAD suffer from extreme anxiety and are in fact compliant with their medication. Nevertheless, there is perhaps a tendency for clinicians to overestimate patient compliance. Patients are particularly likely to be concerned about physical or psychological dependence on medication. It is well worth checking not only with the patient, but perhaps also with the family, whether medication is in fact taken as prescribed.
Comorbid substance use
In the presence of active alcohol or substance use, it may be necessary to shift the emphasis of treatment towards a substance use disorder as the primary diagnosis, with the anxiety as a secondary problem. Detoxification is typically a first step in the management of these patients.[26,27]
Comorbid personality disorders
Although antidepressants may be useful, additional interventions such as psychotherapy may be helpful in patients with chronic anxiety and comorbid personality disorder. While improvement in anxiety symptoms may reduce maladaptive behaviour in patients with comorbid personality disorder, there are other patients (e.g. those with borderline personality disorder) in whom the personality disorder itself may need to be a major target of treatment.
Underlying medical disorder
Patients with GAD who fail to show any noticeable response to treatment should be thoroughly reassessed for the possibility of an underlying medical condition. A range of different medical disorders may lead to chronic anxiety, including endocrine disorders (e.g.hyperthyroidism), respiratory disorders (e.g. chronic obstructive pulmonary disorders), cardiac disorders (e.g. congestive heart failure), and others. If present, such disorders naturally require specific intervention. Note that when using a benzodiazepine in patients with liver dysfunction, consider using those metabolised only by conjugation (e.g. lorazepam, oxazepam).
Pharmacokinetic issues
Drug-drug interactions may result in a sub therapeutic dose of the prescribed antidepressant.
Psychosocial issues
In some cases, a diagnosis of an adjustment disorder with anxious features may be more accurate than that of GAD, and a psychotherapeutic approach therefore indicated. This factor may partially explain high rates of placebo response in some clinical trials in GAD. In other cases of chronic anxiety, psychosocial factors may been during and therefore continuously complicate treatment of GAD until given independent attention.
Where there is only a partial response to an initial 12-week trial, it is prudent to re-evaluate the patient and to consider switching to another antidepressant within the same class or to a different class (e.g. SSRI to SNRI or agomelatine, SNRI to SSRI or agomelatine), or augmentation.[24] Neither augmentation nor switching strategies in GAD have been well researched. Augmentation offers the advantage of retaining any possible gains from the first agent, but the potential disadvantages of polypharmacy (more side-effects, drug interactions).[28] When insomnia is present, the use of an appropriate agent (e.g. non-benzodiazepine gamma-amino-butyric acid (GABA)-ergic hypnotics such as zolpidem, agomelatine, ormirtazapine) may be considered.[24] If comorbid depression is present, augmentation with bupropion, buspirone, or an atypical antipsychotic may be considered. Similarly, if there is a comorbid bipolar disorder, a mood stabiliser, anticonvulsant or an atypical antipsychotic may be considered. Augmentation with psychotherapy is another important consideration.